Excitedly walking into the theater to watch If I Stay left me with hopes that I would walk out with satisfaction and a close level of love you all know I hold for the book.
That didn't happen.
Sure, I did use the tissues, but who wouldn't cry at Mia's grandfather's speech? But more tears were piercing the backs of my eyes as I watched how the film murdered the sole purpose of why I loved the book in the first place.
Usually, I don't watch adaptations and hate them. Actually, I have never hated a book to movie adaptation before a few days ago (that is disregarding Percy Jackson, which I don't really consider an 'adaptation' anyways). But this movie discovered each and every way to pinch my nerves, annoy me tremendously, and nearly had me yelling at the big screen in front of thirty people.
Adam.
Adam.
Adam.
That was all that this movie revolved around: Adam. Half the movie was filled with Mia and Adam frantically eating each others faces, not-really-in-the-book teenage sex, and Adam's reluctant attitude to be the supporting and loving boyfriend he was in the book. Most of the flash backs featured I did not recall being in the book; most scenes of Adam replaced the exceedingly important scenes of Mia's family. Sure, they still left in some crucial family scenes that supported the story's message and the emotions that it's supposed to bring, but honestly, it is like the producers just said: "Since this is based off a YA book, and our audience mainly consists of hormonal teenagers, we should add an overly generous amount of make out scenes, a hint of sex, and overly dramatic relationship problems that young adults will die for. Those kids won't care that we just made this all about teenagers' confusing relationships and completely ignored the underlying message of the power of love and choices and the immortal support of friends and family that the book revolves around."
…
Do you understand what I mean?
The reason I loved the book so much is because of the message that it dumped upon me. The realization of how much love, support, and memories were gifted upon me by my family and friends as a privileged human being. The recognition of how much I truly love and care about the people I used to take for granted. Yes, Adam was in the book, and yes, I liked him and his role in the book. I had nothing against book-Adam; in all sincerity, I loved the Adam that I read about and his and Mia's relationship. But what I really loved about the book was that it was a love story without technically being a love story. The movie butchered this aspect, making it a complete love story, that was, well, completely a love story.
I'm not saying it was a horrible movie, but it wasn't as good as an adaption as it could've been.

